At one point in this book, Jimmy Bowen, then head of Capitol Records Nashville, pauses from reading the notes on the cover of an independent album and asks his guest, “So who the hell are you, man?” Cleve Francis, a 46-year-old cardiologist with a thriving practice in northern Virginia, gives the honest answer: “I’ma cardiologist.” “That’syour problem,” says Bowen, and signs him to a three-album deal.
Do My Heart Good has lots of scenes like that. Francis grew up in Jennings, Louisiana, under what he calls a segregated “dome” of fear and unwritten rules, where the town’s Carnegie library was closed to him. His mother saved coins in a cupboard jar to buy him a Sears Silvertone guitar. From there, the book follows his two vocations. Medicine took him through Southern University and the Medical College of Virginia. Music took him through the folk clubs. He paid for a video for Love Light himself, CMT put it into rotation, and Bowen saw it one afternoon after playing golf.
What follows is the best part of the book. Francis records Tourist in Paradise with Paul Franklin and Reggie Young and gets a handshake from Garth Brooks. He also wins over Ralph Emery: asked whether he should be called Cleve or Dr Francis, he replies, “It depends. Do you have insurance?” Label boss Bowen had warned him about what he called “the Redneck Factor“, and country radio proved to be an impenetrable wall. One program director refused to play a Bowen production because it was “out of tune“. None of the singles climbed higher than number 47. Francis found himself caught in a familiar trap: too white for Black radio, too Black for white radio.
What makes the book an enjoyable read is the lack of bitterness, which Francis compares to castor oil: it tastes awful and does little good. When a hotel guest tosses him his car keys, taking the newly signed major-label artist for a valet, Francis tells the story with a wry shrug and his mother’s advice to “know who you are“. Instead of retreating quietly, he spent his last year in Nashville founding the Black Country Music Association. His writing style is engaging, with a wry humour and well-developed sense of irony.
The casual country music listener will value the chapter A Secret History, a quick primer on Lesley Riddle, DeFord Bailey, Arnold Shultz, Linda Martell and others whose part in country music’s story was long pushed to the margins. It sits well alongside the current conversation sparked by Rhiannon Giddens and The War and Treaty, both name-checked in Bill Ivey’s thoughtful foreword.
Francis is a self-confessed “pack rat” who rebuilds decades-old conversations from his journals, and the dialogue can feel a little polished at times. A few chapters wander, and his fondness for a pop-culture simile occasionally slows the pace. But this is small stuff; the book overall is fun, and if it drifts a bit, then that only feels like the twists of a natural storyteller.
The ending highlights that this book should be filmed, as it has the best cinematic conclusion. Keeping a promise to his mother to be “brave enough to come back“, Francis returns to his practice, puts on a white coat and answers a page from A&E. He never became a country star, but he put a crack in the dome that others have pushed open a bit further. This is a warm, readable, and important book building on the conversation about the place of minorities in Country Music.
Despite the occasionally self-deprecating way of the book, his music is really good. I hadn’t heard it before, and I’m guessing not many AUK readers have either. That’s an oversight… The video below is a good example of his later work, but Bandcamp has a 21-track album with a range of originals and covers. This shows that the country music was a possibly unhelpful diversion. His true place would have been in the company of Bill Withers and Gil Scott-Heron as a “missing link between soul and folk music.”
Related
