
Birthday Cake Records reissue an iconic early 21st-century folk roots album on vinyl for the first time.
If you were looking for an album that defined acoustic folk roots music, you’d have to go a long way to beat the debut album of a well-below-the-radar group called The Be Good Tanyas, and to find them, you would have to go to Canada. Sadly, the group no longer exists, as the members have all moved on to other things since, but their 2001 release Blue Horse was so good that Q Magazine named it one of the 50 best albums of the year.
Frazey Ford (songwriter, vocals, guitar and mandolin) is probably the best known of the group, as she has had success as a solo artist, particularly with the excellent Obadiah. Samantha Parton (no relation, and also vocals, guitar and mandolin) was also a writer and singer, who subsequently formed a duet with early The Be Good Tanyas 4th member, Jolie Holland (the only American in the original line-up; she left before Blue Horse was released) on a rather good album, Wildflower Blues in 2017, and released several in her own name; there was little commercial success. Trish Klein (vocals, electric guitar, and banjo) had a modicum of success post The Be Good Tanyas, with her collaboration in the group Po’ Girl with the esteemed Alison Russell. The girls met at a tree-planting camp, and they busked around for a while, refining their sound, which originated from various sources (including trip-hop and spoken word collaborations) and recording a self-released version of their debut album as part of a student project involving instructor Garth Futcher, before venturing into Futcher’s home studio to create the more intimate album that was released internationally on Nettwerk Records in 2001.
Despite releasing two further albums in 2003 (Chinatown) and 2006 (Hello Love), Blue Horse is their defining moment, because it brought together three disparate artists and created a loose acoustic style that expanded upon the strictures of bluegrass and Appalachian folk and blended this with gospel and country roots to produce a homogeneous whole. One might argue that their subsequent albums were a little more polished, but they did not have the same impact as Blue Horse, which benefits from fascinating interpretations of traditional and old-time folk songs. The band took a hiatus in 2008, reformed a few years later for some live shows, but has not released any new music, and the differing directions that they took did not lead to any reformation.
It is an album of mixed musical styles and songwriting. Five of the tracks originate from traditional Appalachian or vintage folk songs, including Stephen Foster’s 1848 minstrel song Oh Susanna, which is slowed right down until it almost becomes a lullaby, sung by Ford in her rather quirky yet captivating voice, accompanied in part by Holland’s mournful fiddle. Rain and Snow is another often-covered, rather sinister traditional early 20th-century song, long associated with bluegrass musicians like Bill Monroe and Del McCoury but also recorded by The Grateful Dead. The Be Good Tanyas’ version is quite unique, with Ford delivering lead vocals in front of an upbeat tempo supported by some great percussion and acoustic guitars in the background, taking it somewhat away from the bluegrass and bluesy interpretations previously. Similarly, Lakes of Pontchartrain is a 19th-centuryfolk ballad, covered many times, often by Irish artists such as Paul Brady and Planxty, that features Holland on lead with a slightly harsh-sounding vocal, supported by some great acoustic guitar/banjo interplay. One should not forget the contribution of Holland, who was not particularly on board with the direction of travel for the band, and went back south to her homeland, but only after major input to the album.
There are seven new songs written individually or collectively; on an album of excellent songs, Ford’s brilliant, slow ballad Broken Telephone (with fine electric guitar licks by Klein on a song about relationship miscommunication) and her interpretation of fellow Vancouver musician Geoff Berner’s Light Enough to Travel, that closes the album in thumping form on a somewhat pop-rock arrangement, about keeping your moving options open when you feel oppressed or harassed, are this writer’s current favourites – “They say “look here comes another one” / And I don’t know what they mean yet / And I say / Keep it light enough to travel / Don’t let it all unravel”.
And there are other delights: Holland and Parton’s The Littlest Birds that opens the album, and maybe The Be Good Tanyas’ most well-known song, is like a companion piece to the closer (“Wake you up in the mornin’ so early / Just to tell you I got the wanderin’ blues“) as Ford’s distinctive voice kicks the album off with a lightly shuffling number, trading lead vocals with Parton with a demonstration as the track progresses of the wonderful harmonies that this group deliver. In some ways they match those on the famous Trio albums with Dolly Parton, Linda Ronstadt and Emmylou Harris, but the voices are a little coarser (not in a bad way) and more powerful than the delicate Trio group. Think the quirky vocals of the McGarrigle Sisters or Iris DeMent for a closer comparison, but a bit louder; Ford also sings lead on the other song, which is associated with The Be Good Tanyas, Only In The Past, a lovely lilting reflective song about memories, enhanced by Holland’s lovely fiddle again, soloing over Klein’s gorgeous banjo in the background; this track was played by Bob Harris on his show after he discovered the album while perusing the contents of a record shop in Nashville. Parton delivers two more songs, the slightly odd lullaby Dogsong, and the quieter cautionary Don’t You Fall.
The Be Good Tanyas’ instrumentation could take equal billing to their idiosyncratic voices, perhaps a function of the remastering that was effected between their original self-release in 2000 and Nettwerk’s worldwide release in 2001. The fascinating interplay of their acoustic instruments is enhanced with some fine rhythm support by Paul Clifford and sometimes Brendan Ostrander (drums) and Andrew Burden (bass). Mathieu Gagne plays some searing electric violin on the interpretation of the traditional English folk song The Cuckoo (now called The Coo Coo Bird), which has passed through many lyrical variations from England via Scotland, Canada and the US. It’s a mid-tempo song that probably has the most identifiable Appalachian roots sound on the album.
It’s a shame that this fine harmony folk-roots group did not stay together for long, as the members of the group left to follow other paths, but this reissue is a timely reminder of the individual talents of the group members, lyrically, vocally and instrumentally, and it’s certainly worth exploring, perhaps especially in its new vinyl offering.
Related
