
Mary Gauthier was something of a late starter, releasing her first album when she was 35 years old (in 1997), following a period of addiction and running a restaurant in Boston. Since that time, she has been sober, released a further 10 albums, most notably Mercy Now in 2005, probably her most well-known album, Rifles and Rosary Beads in 2018 (an album that was recorded in conjunction with military veterans), and, now in 2026, probably her most important album, Reckoning, which has received almost unanimous critical praise. As the title implies, it contemplates a reckoning in life, be it personal, political or spiritual. On the album, Gauthier explores in depth the link between these reckonings. AUK’s Fred Arnold got to handle his first interview for the magazine with one of the great songwriters of modern times. Our interview took place on November 3rd, and readers can probably pick up the tension about the outcome of the US Midterm elections in her words. It came across in her voice also. We hope she is a little more relaxed about things now that the result is known. Gauthier’s partner is the fine singer-songwriter Jaimee Harris, hence the mention of her in this interview.
Mary Gauthier: Fred?
Americana UK: Hi Mary, may I call you Mary?
MG: You can call me Mary. We just had a power outage, so I’m trying to do this on my phone, and I think I got it. Is this thing working?
AUK: Yes. It’s an auspicious day that we got to talk.
MG: I’m very nervous, so you get a highly tense version of Mary.
AUK: Maybe it’s an omen. I’m also nervous, and I’ll explain quickly why. This is the first interview I have done for AUK, and I happen to be speaking to one of my favourite artists. I know you are a great interviewer and a great interviewee, so I just wanted you to know how I am feeling, exactly how you were feeling when you went to interview Vince Gill.
MG: I was scared shitless, actually. But, just think of this as a conversation. We’ll have a good conversation; that’s kind of a good interview, y’know. And get to know each other.
AUK: I am also conscious of the fact that you have had some very good interviews. I saw one yesterday with Chloe Aftel, a female interviewer who is very empathetic to the sort of questions that you might want to answer. I don’t know if you feel the same way towards male interviewers.
MG: Oh, I don’t think about that. Y’know, it’s more about do we click as people. I’m not that gender oriented. You know, for most of my career and even today, most of the people who buy my records and come to my shows are men, my age. And I think there are lots of good reasons for that.
AUK: I was at King’s Place on your last tour, and I enjoyed that immensely.
MG: Yeah, I enjoy that venue. I love that place; it’s beautiful. We’re coming back in November 2027.
AUK: Yes, I know, I have my tickets already.
MG: (laughs) Thank you.
AUK: I also happen to be going to see Jaimee Harris in the next week or so.
MG: She’s coming over for her first tour across the pond, solo. She’s excited and nervous.
AUK: Let me kick off with a couple of questions about the new album that drove this interview. I don’t know if you knew that it was me who reviewed it for Americana UK.
MG: Oh, yes, and I really appreciate it (Gauthier had written of her pleasure at the review on Facebook).
AUK: One of the things that has followed from the album is the series of interviews that you are doing with your co-writers. You’ve never done an album entirely with co-writers except Rifles and Rosary Beads, and I’ve never seen an artist interview co-writers for the purposes of getting more of an explanation of the process.
MG: It came across, sort of, conversationally with my team, because my co-writers are such extraordinary songwriters and interesting human beings. We said, you know what, let’s do it, and we found a spot for the interviews. We call it a podcast, but it’s not. I’m not going to keep going; that’s the only one. There’ll be about 10, maybe eleven, and we have these conversations. You know my co-writers are such extraordinary songwriters. We just thought we would lift the curtain on the songwriting process and sort of let the people watch us talk about that.
AUK: I thought it was very fascinating because you don’t normally get that sort of explanation of how the process evolves.
MG: Often we don’t even know how it evolves. It’s mysterious. We’re both just sort of in a trance at a certain point, and it moves real fast. We’re chasing ideas that come and go like electrical volts, and then it’s over. We realize, wow, this is pretty good. How did that happen?
AUK: I’ve listened to all your albums, and this is the shortest album you’ve made, as far as I’m aware. It’s only got nine songs. Is that because you felt you established everything you wanted to say in terms of the linkage of the ‘reckoning’ between all the tracks, or is it because you wanted to simply get it out and therefore when you’d got nine songs that made the album long enough?
MG: I feel like I said what I had to say, you know? I think albums, for me, are an opportunity to say what’s needing to be said. Some are longer, and some are shorter. I covered a lotta ground in those songs, and that’s what I’m trying to do: sort myself out and my thoughts and my feelings and, and the world around me. Once we got to eight songs, I felt like we had it, and then we added that one song that was not written by me at the end that I feel sums up all that me and my co-writers were saying. For 20 years, I wanted to record that song and finally found the way to make it mean something in context to what I was doing. So, I said what I needed to say for now, but I’m like, today I’m gonna be working on new songs that I got coming already. They’re new thoughts.
AUK: Well, there are always new thoughts, aren’t there? I love the linkage of all the different reckonings that you’re talking about: personal, societal and political. This is a very political album, but the politics are not direct. It’s very subtle in your use of imagery and metaphor. That’s fascinating. The last track is one that you have played live. Do you feel as positive as that track implies?
MG: Well, it’s kind of open-ended. That train could be death, you know? It could be the approaching mortality at the end. It could be dealing with and healing from grief. Metaphors are slippery little lizards that have many interpretations. They mean different things at different times in your life. In the context of this record, it is hopeful in that we are going to get through this catastrophic disaster in the United States of America and in an awful lot of places around the world. We’re going to get through this and find our way. And there will be a reconciling, a reckoning, and we are going to make it right. I believe that, and we have evidence of that, but we also have evidence of the opposite. All I can do is go by my instincts.
AUK: I am interested in the process of the album, as it sounds different from other albums you have made. Your producer used Nebraska as a sort of template for the sound. Even with just acoustic guitar backing like Springsteen, you’ve got these lovely little embellishments that your producer has brought to the album to make it more interesting, like the echo in your voice in the first track. How did you come to use that rather than something that was a little more ‘polished’, a bit more expansive, shall we say?
MG: Well, I felt like the songs warranted it, and I didn’t feel like getting a band together. I didn’t feel like doing all the complex things involved in making a studio recording with a lot of other people. I just wanted to record the songs. So I went to Austin and thought, I’ve been doing this for a long time; maybe I’m good enough now and have this down enough that my singing and playing my songs can hold an audience in a record setting. I know I can do it on stage, but will I be able to do it on a record? I felt these were the songs for that and didn’t want to wait. There was an urgency, and still is, around these songs. And I needed to get it out in the world – voice, guitar, harmonica, let’s go! After recording, I sent it to my guy in Nashville, and he added a little bit of what we call the cinematic touch. He threw on some reverb, some percussive stuff, but not a lot. This is a very stripped-down record, and I wanted it to sound analog, like a human being in a studio. I didn’t want it perfect. I didn’t want it to feel like computers fixed it. I wanted it just to be me, the songs, and the listener with a candle, listening in at night or on a night drive. I think people like its warmth.
AUK: Absolutely, analogue is warm like vinyl. I was interested in that comment because back when you released Mercy Now,I don’t know if you read the review that the BBC did, but they suggested that album would have been better if it had been recorded as a live album with just you and guitar. You’ve done exactly that almost twenty years later with the new album.
MG: That might be right, but I wasn’t ready yet. I hadn’t gotten the maturity; I hadn’t gotten the road experience and didn’t have the confidence yet. It takes confidence to do this, and that has to be earned. I didn’t come in with that; I had to go out and get that. It took a lot of miles.
AUK: At the concert at King’s Place with Jaime Harris, you were talking on stage about the benefits that each of you had brought to the other’s music. She taught you, or encouraged you, to use your voice more, be a bit more expansive.
MG: A singer of her magnitude, she’s got a strong, powerful voice, and she’s got this confidence. She’s been singing harmony since she was 12 years old, and she just comes in and nails it. That provides a real foundation for me, and it helps me stay on pitch. When you sing with a great singer, you become a better singer. Absolutely.
AUK: Chloe Aftel picked up on exactly the same point, about how she felt your voice was more expansive on this album than it had been on previous ones.
MG: Yeah, less timid. That’s what it is. I’m going past what I think I am capable of and surprising myself, trying new things to see what’s there. I’m still learning and growing. I’m so glad that the songs supported my ability to deliver them, and my ability to deliver them supported the songs. Keeping those things in alignment is not something you can control. It’s hoping they are working out for the best.
AUK: Do you have an inkling that the album might be up for any kind of award as it has received phenomenal positive press coverage?
MG: Oh, I always get good press coverage. That doesn’t change a lot (laughs). I’ve never been skewered, but awards are funny things. They’re very political, and, as I’ve been in the business for all these decades, I see kinda how it works. People with big record companies and big management companies run large-scale campaigns. Who knows what’s gonna happen? I don’t focus on that as much as reaching the people when I get on stage and sing these songs. That’s what I have the ability and power to control and what I’m focused on. I’m playing a show on Thursday in Minneapolis and, as you know, that was the city that was under siege by ICE in January and two beautiful young people were killed. They shot them dead, and there’s been no accountability. So when I go to Minnesota on Thursday, I’m singing to people that are traumatized. My emphasis is on connecting there and letting them know they are not alone.
AUK: The first track on the album is Alcohol and Adderall, and that traces back to something that is very familiar in your life. Do you still find it easy, difficult or necessary to write about addiction and drug abuse?
MG: That is such a part of my life. I think it is just unavoidable. I mean, I’ve been sober 36 years, so it’s not in me, but it’s certainly around me. My memories are loaded with stories of the years that I lost. But you know, the interesting thing about this song is that the character who is singing is not an addict, maybe in love with an addict, and that is a whole other kind of pain. But I think it is always going to be part of the story, ’cause I’m never cured. I’m always carrying it. If I don’t know every day that recovery is the most important thing, you’re lost. What’s most important is to get my head to the pillow tonight; then it’s a good day, no matter what happens.
AUK: When you were talking to Vince Gill, I read about how the track These Times came about. I gather that he was the one who originally brought this to you. It was not a song that you had thought of doing. Is that something that happens with the co-writes, or are you the one who has the ideas and brings the first draft?
MG: It’s different every time. With Beth Neilsen Chapman, she’s opposed to going into a co-write with an idea. She doesn’t like ideas; she wants to come up with one together. She really believes in the mystery of the process and likes starting with nothing. Vince had the idea, but not for the song. He had the title.
AUK: That was from talking to Mavis Staples?
MG: Yeah, because Mavis had said ‘we’ve seen some times’, and Vince thought that could be a song, but he didn’t have one. So we had to find a way to get a narrator to start telling the story. We tried a lot of different things before we found that guy talking in the song.
AUK: I gather it’s quite a lot longer with more verses than the final version.
MG: Oh, God, it took us months. We wrote so many verses. I mean, it wasn’t exactly Leonard Cohen’s Hallelujah length, but we damn sure had 20, and then we had to figure what was most important to this guy. What did he really need to say?
AUK: You’ve touched on ageing and mortality, and that runs through quite a few of the tracks on the album. Has the ageing process changed the way you look at how you write about mortality?
MG: The ageing process changes how I write about everything, changes how I look out at the world. So mortality is on the table. I’m 64, and I’ll be 65 in March. It’s time to write a will; it’s time to get on Medicare. I’ve got friends all around me that are dealing with health ailments. It’s inevitable, and I’m not going to pretend like I’m 30. I know that a lot of older artists do because it’s unitary, but I’m gonna be honest and vulnerable and true, sing about what my concerns are for real. There’s joy in knowing that, today, I’m healthy, but the reality is, who knows tomorrow? I have friends coming down with Parkisnsons and MS, and my friend Gretchen Peters has throat cancer. I wanna seize the day that I’m healthy, be productive and make the most of it. It’s not a given. When you’re young, you think it’s a given, and as you get older you know it’s not. It’s a gift.
AUK: The other motif is the train, which I guess is the notion of travelling down a track, going somewhere.
MG: Trains are perfect metaphors in that you can make a train mean anything, for just about any subject that’s important to human beings. There are so many songs, and it may be something to do with the imagination of the American people. We remain fixated on trains even though we don’t have any, at least no good ones. So the imagery remains, and they’re romanticised as well.
AUK: They are probably more romanticised in America. We have train songs in the UK as well, but they don’t have the same mythology as in the US.
MG: Yes, that’s because this country is so damn big; it should probably contain six or eight countries.
AUK: You were talking with Aaron Lee Tasjan about the title track; that it was the last one to be written to appear on the album.
MG: Isn’t that funny, that it came last? Until we had another song which summed up what we were doing, I didn’t have a record. So I was super excited when I started to write with him, and this thing started coming through. It seemed like, oh man, this might be the title track; we can pull this off. It feels like the summation of what I think is happening in the songs that are all around me.
AUK: It’s an extraordinary song. You cut it down. It was actually a much longer song with all the verses.
MG: Yeah, I made it more concise. Once the imagery started coming, I felt all in, and so did Aaron. But we had a lot going on, and we had to edit it down and make it really tight. I think we ended up with what needed to be there.
AUK: I don’t know if it was intended to be angry, but it certainly comes across like that.
MG: It’s a mixture of angry and determined, like Springsteen. We’re angry and determined to turn this thing around; we can’t let this happen. I think most of us, on my side anyway, have been bewildered at what has been happening for ten years, and we can’t stop this madness, so yeah, we’re angry and are committed and determined to stop it. We’re still trying to figure out how, ’cause this contagion is everywhere and it is very hard to stop.
AUK: Yes, I was in America in June 2016. I had been at Telluride, and when the result came through, it was a complete and utter surprise, not just to Americans but to everyone around the world. And we are all suffering the consequences.
MG: Y’know, I didn’t even know how to talk about it. I had an election party in 2016. I was so sure that Hillary Clinton had it. I was positive, and she did win the popular vote; she just didn’t win the Electoral College, which needs to be abolished because it was put in place by racists. But I think, after what happened that night, that everybody left in tears. I was going to have a party tonight, but I’m not; I’m gonna go to the movies. I’m scared to have a party tonight because I don’t want to put people through that again.
All indications are that things are gonna start changing, but who knows? Who can trust anything at this point? We are in a house of cards and a hall of mirrors. The thing feels ethereal, like nothing is real. Who’s telling the truth; who is lying? Whose votes are being counted; which machines are being rigged? What’s happening from outer space, for God’s sake? There’s just craziness, so yeah, tonight’s party is off the table. I’ve been doing this since college, and we had people over on Election Results Night. You know, win some, lose some, but nothing like this. This is a nightmare, and we all need it to end. So, all we can do is vote and hope, and speak up and try very hard to help each other down here in the masses, as this nightmare continues to unfold.
AUK: You’ve done a few interviews since the album came out, and we’re very grateful for your time, but is there any question that nobody has yet asked you about the album or events surrounding the album that you wish you had been asked?
MG: No, I think we’ve covered it. I would just like to put on record that I think this is probably the strongest record I’ve made. I feel like it has got a lot in there that is me, but it also has a lot in there that is now, and the record is reflective of what we are going through now. As a storyteller, I have never written a collection of stories that are stronger than these, and I am just proud of it and want people to hear it. I know how to break through the cacophony of voices and people saying things that are getting a lot of attention. I’m not a ‘getting attention kind of person’, but I feel this is my strongest album, and in that, the stories are timeless and timely. I don’t know if my ego will let me say that, but it matters beyond me. It doesn’t matter that I wrote it; it matters because the art is consequential and significant. It’s not about me so much as it is about the world around me and the human condition.
Related
