While doing community service, awkward loner Aubrey Flint (John Bradley) helps stage an amateur production of A Christmas Carol in order to save a care home.
The ‘Underdog Community Puts On A Show’ subgenre has become a staple of British comedy films. They all follow roughly the same template: a down-at-heel gang of misfits and eccentrics band together to save the town hall/social club/pub/hospital sofa. It began in semi-social realist form with Brassed Off and The Full Monty, but has since morphed into something cosier and safer: Fisherman’s Friends, Quartet, Mother’s Pride. Now comes Merry Christmas Aubrey Flint, which takes the well-worn template and adds a Dickensian twist.
The rather convoluted premise is as follows: Aubrey Flint (John Bradley) is a Napoleon-obsessed French boy whose family emigrates to York, where he is bullied. Then his mum dies. (This is in the first ten minutes.) He grows up to be a curmudgeonly man who hates Christmas — à la Scrooge — but loves model armies and correct grammar.
After an acutely absurd confrontation with a pensioner on a mobility scooter over a snowglobe, Aubrey has to do community service at a care home, where he meets the kindly manager Ellen (Loki’s Sophia Di Martino) and fellow community servicer Kugan (Ghosts’ Kiell Smith-Bynoe). The care home is under threat from a villainous developer (Dustin Demri-Burns), so the misfits and eccentrics who make up the residents (which include Celia Imrie and Nigel Planer) stage a production of A Christmas Carol, which will — somehow — save their bacon.
Taking this meta approach to Dickens — the tale of a Scrooge-like character, reluctantly staging the story of Scrooge — is almost fresh enough to feel like it’s not the same old Dickens story retold (especially being released a week before Johnny Depp’s Ebenezer). And there’s plenty to admire here, from its storied cast (Imrie lends some welcome gravitas) to the film’s hard-to-begrudge good-natured earnestness.
You just wish it would treat its audience a little less like primary-school children. Everything is so caricatured and exaggerated that it feels like watching Nativity! for old folk. Richard E. Grant — unrecognisable in a ludicrous wig and moustache, looking like a cross between Donald Sutherland from Don’t Look Now and Geppetto from Pinocchio — is about as convincing as he was in the Traitors castle. The baddies, from the sneering Hugo to a dreaded health-and-safety officer, are somehow more cartoonish than Scrooge himself, yet the film offers no redemption arcs there. The tone is both schmaltzy and miserable, so any attempt at jokes feels almost inappropriate. And it has a soundtrack so middle-of-the-road, Michael Bublé must be wondering why he didn’t get a call. Maybe Scrooge had a point.
Cheesier than a Christmas Day Stinking Bishop, this has a very sweet heart, but is almost fatally generic and derivative. Humbug!
